Somewhere else entirely

ON THE INTERNET, everyone's in the same place. Or so it appears at first sight. It could the the least geographic place ever to exist; and it clearly is a "place", to anyone who's spent any time in it. Physically, the Internet stretches from the South Pole to 77 degrees North, and almost encircles the globe. As an experience, it's somewhere else entirely.

Once you've connect your computer to the Internet and set out searching for information, you rapidly get a "feel" for "where" you are in this web connecting over 20 million users around the world. This sense, though, is based more on logical connections between pieces of information than on physical location.

As I write this, the library at the University of St. George (in Utah? Canada? don't know!) is, because I hit one key too many, trying to locate every book it holds on geography. Sorry. If I remember rightly, my connection to St. George runs from London through Koeln in Germany and Las Vegas in Nevada. It's quite possible that alternate chunks of information are coming back from Nevada to Germany in different directions round the globe.

At the same time, an electronic mail message which I forwarded to myself is on a journey from London to London via Frankfurt and Manchester. The original author of the e-mail composed it in a word-processor in Toronto and "up-loaded" the text to a computer there, instructing the machine to send it to a dozen people around the world. I want to "publish" it to another 100 people linked to a different computer network. Both networks are connected to the Internet: sending a message to myself via Germany is easier and cheaper than fetching it onto my computer and up-loading it again.

Despite surface popularisation by US Vice President Al Gore and Doonesbury cartoonist Gary Trudeau, it's probably in order to explain a little of what the Internet is.

HISTORY

The roots of the Internet lie in the US Department of Defense's attempts in the late 1960s to construct a command and communication system which would function after a nuclear attack. The result was ARPAnet, named after the Advanced Research Projects Agency. In this deeply decentralised structure, messages are divided into "packets". Each packet is sent off in the general direction of its destination, by whatever route is available. On the way across the US, each packet might be handled by half-a-dozen or more different computers. Each one detects a surviving link and forwards packets towards the destination, where they are re-assembled in order.

The ARPAnet technology is indeed robust. A columnist in the Communications of the (US) Association for Computing Machinery reported that the Iraqi military command uses it, and that this is why their communications held up under massive bombardment in 1990.

ARPAnet was taken up enthusiastically by computer programmers working on DoD contracts, who began the tradition of using the system to circulate gossip and arguments as well as working data. US universities adopted it next, as a means for enabling researchers to share computers across cities, and then across the country.

Technology-based companies set up connections to maintain high- speed communications with the DoD and the universities. As students left university and lost their precious Internet connections, a burgeoning industry provided access over the public phone network from modems attached to personal computers at home.

TOPOGRAPHY

The physical layout of the Net was first determined by the location of US military bases. It's still the case that you're more likely to find a high-quality connection to a region with a US base than to one without. The major determinant for the current Net has been the location of super-computer centres.

The "backbones" of both the US academic Internet and JANET (the Joint Academic Network) in the UK were originally funded and built to share out super-computer resources. In the US "pork- barrel" politics -- elected representatives lobbying for lucrative or prestigious projects in their districts -- have more to do with the location of such sites than the more mundane concerns of efficiency or cost.

Universities and government establishments with super-computers are often connected by physical links of copper or fibre-optic cable. Other establishments, and commercial operations, usually connect to their nearest point on the backbone through data links, leased from public telecommunications providers. These also send packets of data by the best or cheapest currently available route.

An estimate compiled for the 1993 edition of the publication TeleGeography shows eleven million megabytes of data moved within the USA in June 1993. (The text of a fat paperback is about half a megabyte.) Traffic between the US and the rest of the world was about one million megabytes, and that between European countries about half a million megabytes.

TERRITORY

This balance of trade reflects the Internet's origin as a network of local computer networks in the US. A significant step in its evolution into a global network of national networks came with the first links to JANET, using a transatlantic cable shared with NASA, in 1979.

By the end of February 1994, national computer networks in 72 countries had full connections to the Internet. Cyprus, Fiji, Indonesia, Iran, Lebanon, the Ukraine, and the US territory of Guam had joined this list since June 1993. One country had been added as Czechoslovakia divided, and something had gone wrong with the connection to the United Arab Emirates.

A "full connection", in this context, is one which can handle high-speed transfer of large files, such as satellite images. From a site with a full connection, you can (given the right passwords) use the computers at any other such site as if you were there.

A professor of mathematics from Maryland recently spent a week in London without colleagues realising he was away. He continued work on the university computer with no sign -- to anyone except the computer network administrator -- that he'd gone off campus. His colleagues mostly communicate with him by sending electronic mail messages, even to a different floor of the same building.

It is currently possible to send electronic mail to at least a few people in a further 56 countries -- an increase of 21 in eight months. At the current rate of growth, there will be e-mail to essentially all the 239 countries and territories in the International Standards Organisation list by the end of the century.

According TeleGeography, the furthest northern reach of the Net and its connected nets (sometimes collectively called "the Matrix") is at Thule (Qaanaaq) in Greenland, at 77 degrees N. There are sites at the University of the South Pacific in Fiji (178E), and in Honolulu (157W). In between, obviously, is mostly water -- with a few ships running e-mail over Inmarsat satellite links.

The southernmost point on the Net is at the US South Pole base. Indeed, the Net is the only public means of communication with Antarctica -- you can't phone, you can't post a letter, but you can send electronic mail there.

Some of the world's poorest countries are among those already connected, for the benefit of the aid and development organisations which can afford to use e-mail. The Rio de Janeiro- based Association for Progressive Communications, through its UK affiliate GreenNet, is setting up low-cost "FIDOnet" links to countries from Ethiopia to Bangladesh. FIDOnet consists of programs running on extremely basic personal computers, which dial each other up over the public telephone network to exchange messages every few hours. Hobbyists in the developed world run thousands of such machines.

POPULATION & LANGUAGE

Despite the explosion of the Net across the globe, the visible population is overwhelmingly American. Of those participating in discussions in Usenet news-groups, 90% appear to be based in the USA. This is, however, difficult to confirm. This author, for example, has e-mail "accounts" which by historical accident appear to be in the US and Germany. There are active news-groups in German and Japanese, but none feature in the top 40.

Even more strikingly, over 90% of those giving recognisable names seem to be male, presumably due to the established base of users in computer science and the hard sciences. Many women use initials only -- or even male names -- to avoid unwelcome messages from socially retarded male undergraduates.

POLITICAL ORGANISATION & CULTURE

Usenet is frequently described as "the world's largest functioning anarchy". The setting up of a new "official" news- group is determined by direct democracy -- electronic votes, in which any of the roughly 4 million readers may take part.

Very many discussions are marked by a fiercely individualistic libertarianism of a particularly US flavour. The consensus among those taking part is in favour of a right to absolute freedom of expression, based on the widest interpretation of the First Amendment to the US Constitution -- the government "shall make no law abridging the freedom of the press".

This view is especially strongly protested when any information is removed from the Net -- even, or perhaps particularly, when a system administrator decides that allocating space to erotica is not a particularly high priority for an archive of program code funded by the tax-payer.

ECONOMY

The economy of the Net is rather unusual. With any form of telecommunications, once you've laid fibre or cable or launched satellites, running costs are minimal.

There is no billing system on the Internet. Local system administrators estimate that setting one up would double or treble the cost of keeping the Net going. (By the same token, how much of your phone bill represents the cost of keeping records, issuing bills and processing payments?)

Universities in the US and UK pay a flat-rate annual subscription for unlimited use of all Internet or JANET services. A great deal of organisational work, such as the maintenance of lists of site addresses, is done voluntarily. Services such as the archives of useful program code are operated using spare hardware.

This is bound to change as the number of non-academic users, and the demands they put on system support services, grows. No clear alternative to the economics of voluntary work is apparent.

There are paid-for services, the best-known of which is probably the Clarinet business news feed. This, too, charges an annual fee to each participating sub-network, based on the number of terminals. It offers a reward for information about unauthorised forwarding of information from subscribing sites.

The European-Community-sponsored CITED scheme is developing a framework for transmission of paid-for electronic publications in such a way that they can be read only by users possessing a "smart card". Such a prospect elicits typed shrieks of horror from self-proclaimed "Netizens", who insist that "information wants to be free".

One reason for the Net's voluntarist culture lies in its origins as a mutual support network (in both senses) for computer specialists. From the beginning, those with access saw themselves to be an elite -- as pioneer Ed Krol put it self-mockingly, as "Department of Defense-certified nerds".

This vast and sprawling "place" is indeed a site of influence, which extends into what its inhabitants often refer to as "The Real World (TM)". Those who can communicate fastest can influence events, whether in the financial markets or by bombarding startled Interior Ministers with demands to free imprisoned dissidents.

It's also in the throes of unpredictable change as the Real World invades it -- through geographical spread, through access by individuals, and through the involvement of profit-making corporations and their attendant bevies of lawyers in the much- vaunted Information Superhighway. Watch this space.


[logo]
home

Written:
15 March 1994
An edited version of this article appeared in Geographical magazine. They re-cast it as the geography of the Net, rather than picking up on the Net as a place with (in principle, economics aside) ideography but no geography...
This version is © copyright 1996 Mike Holderness; moral rights are asserted.

Geographers sans frontières: a guide to making use of it


Thanks to Olivier Crepin-Leblond of Imperial College, London, for his (voluntarily maintained) list of access by country.

TeleGeography is published annually in the Autumn by TeleGeography Inc. in Washington DC with the International Institute of Communications in London.

[logo]
articles index